
After a couple weeks away for the holidays the Madden roster updates have returned with #17 set to release on Friday. There is still expected to be another update next week following the divisional round of the playoffs. It’s unknown whether there will be one after the Conference Championships before closing out the year with the final update following the Super Bowl.
Some pretty significant changes this time around. LaDainian Tomlinson finally drops from his 99 rating, though it is only to a 97. Still not enough when compared to someone like DeAngelo Williams who did get a nice bump to 89, but there is little justification that can be made for being eight points behind LT. Brett Favre takes a five point hit down to an 89 while Matt Cassel moves up four points to 85.
Transactions
TE Jerame Tuman – Released by Cardinals
LB Victor Hobson – Signs with Cardinals
HB Najeh Davenport – Released by Colts
T Michael Toudouze – Signs with Colts
CB Adam Jones – Released by Cowboys
FB Casey Cramer – Released by Dolphins
LB Derek Smith – Signs with Dolphins
LB Rich Scanlon – Signs with Giants
DT J’Vonne Parker – Signs with Panthers
QB Craig Nall – Released by Texans
CB David Pittman – Signs with Texans
TE Mark Breuner – Retires
Ratings Up
HB Matt Forte – Bears – 85 to 87 – Ran hard and showed great promise behind a mediocre offensive line and a seemingly bad passing game.
DE Alex Brown – Bears – 85 to 86 – Made some big plays but consistency is still the biggest problem with him.
CB Leon Hall – Bengals – 80 to 82 – Had a better year after getting abused by offenses in his rookie season.
S Chinedum Ndukwe – Bengals – 80 to 84 – The Bengals best player in the secondary this season. Looks to enter next season entrenched as a starter.
HB Fred Jackson – Bills – 81 to 83 – Backup back to Marshawn Lynch who outplayed him most weeks.
LT Ryan Clady – Broncos – 87 to 90 – Elite LT for the Broncos. Everything you heard about how good he is is true.
WR Brandon Marshall – Broncos – 94 to 96 – Has taken the next step as a dominate #1 WR. The numbers are only going to get better.
WR Eddie Royal – Broncos – 82 to 84 – Undersized receiver who proved most critics wrong about the Broncos drafting him too early.
WR Larry Fitzgerald – Cardinals – 97 to 98 – Made more circus type catches vs. an outmatched Falcons secondary.
DE Antonio Smith – Cardinals – 84 to 85 – Has played big all season for the Cardinals.
LB Karlos Dansby – Cardinals – 88 to 89 – Was showing big hitting ability and in the right place at the right time in the 1st round vs. the Falcons.
CB DRC – Cardinals – 81 to 85 – Matched up with Roddy White and came up big. Made a nice leaping INT in addition to solid man coverage.
HB Darren Sproles – Chargers – 82 to 84 – Could be the start of a huge offseason contract. Looks much better than Tomlinson down the stretch.
CB Terence Newman – Cowboys – 95 to 96 – After shedding off injury concerns locked down opposing receivers the rest of the season.
DT Jay Ratliff – Cowboys – 87 to 88 – Racked up 7.5 sacks in impressive fashion for the Cowboys.
LB Bradie James – Cowboys – 88 to 89 – Played pro bowl caliber this season (just ask him).
CB Andre Goodman – Dolphins – 76 to 79 – Was miserable in Detroit in a Cover 2 scheme, played extremely well in man for the Dolphins.
LT Jake Long – Dolphins – 86 to 89 – Dolphins made a good pick and got a solid LT for the next 10 years.
LB Channing Crowder – Dolphins – 86 to 87 – Played kind of like everyone thought he would at the end of the season. Is up for a new contract.
QB Chad Pennington – Dolphins – 85 to 88 – Didn’t get it done vs. the Ravens, but played near mistake free football all season with free agent caliber WR’s playing a big role.
S Yeremiah Bell – Dolphins – 86 to 87 – Emerged as the best player in the Dolphins secondary after showing promise last year before a knee injury.
QB Donovan McNabb – Eagles – 91 to 92 – Has been rolling since the benching. Continues to play with receivers that can’t beat press coverage.
S Quintin Mikell – Eagles – 86 to 89 – The strength of the defense has been the safeties, big reason is Mikell.
S Brian Dawkins – Eagles – 93 to 94 – Whispers of his demise were exaggerated, has been as good as ever this season.
QB Matt Ryan – Falcons – 87 to 89 – Played a shaky rookie playoff game with some rookie throws, but he will be an elite QB in the future.
LT Sam Baker – Falcons – 83 to 85 – Had back issues this season and was banged up in college, but was a fine pass blocker when healthy.
WR Roddy White – Falcons – 93 to 94 – Looks to keep rolling next season with Matt Ryan.
CB Corey Webster – Giants – 90 to 91 – Has really turned it on this season playing excellent football consistently.
CB Rashean Mathis – Jaguars – 96 to 97 – Was an All-Pro before an injury to his knee ended his season. Likes to take the offenses best WR which can’t be said about all elite CB’s.
S Gerald Sensabaugh – Jaguars – 81 to 83 -
HB Thomas Jones – Jets – 90 to 91 – Looked very spry despite Jet beat writers saying otherwise. Ran very hard and was very elusive in space.
WR Calvin Johnson – Lions – 92 to 94 – Was the best player on the field Week 17 vs. the Packers. A QB and a competent staff could produce something never seen.
HB Kevin Smith – Lions – 79 to 81 – Was 24 yards short of a 1,000 with 8 TD’s on the Lions.
HB DeAngelo Williams – Panthers – 86 to 89 – His last half of the season was silly. Looks to keep rolling vs. the Cardinals.
QB Aaron Rodgers – Packers – 86 to 88 – Played an excellent season showing mobility and a cannon arm (and better than Brett).
FS Nick Collins – Packers – 89 to 91 – Was in the QB’s head for the first time in his career this season. Game is slowing down for him.
CB Charles Woodson – Packers – 94 to 95 – The Packers MVP this season.
RT Jeff Otah – Panthers – 79 to 83 – A beast in the run game.
LB Jerod Mayo – Patriots – 84 to 88 – Defensive rookie of the year. Mayo and Guyton could be special on the inside.
QB Matt Cassell – Patriots – 81 to 85 – Granted his receivers did all the work, but made smart decisions and passes all the way until the end.
CB Chris Johnson – Raiders – 71 to 79 – Paired with Asomugha to dominate opposing WR’s when both active. The other Chris Johnson replaced DeAngelo Hall and was better.
G Robert Gallery – Raiders – 85 to 87 – A bright spot on the Raiders offensive line. His shift to guard has helped out his career.
WR Lance Moore – Saints – 80 to 84 – Closed out the year with a big game and led the Saints in all receiving stats.
CB Ike Taylor – Steelers – 92 to 93 – Wide receivers can’t seem to see him lately. He just bats it down and lets them know.
HB Steve Slaton – Texans – 85 to 87 – My vote for top rookie back (Slaton/Forte/Johnson)
WR Andre Johnson – Texans – 97 to 98 – Dominated Charles Tillman and Al Harris to end the season. Is just better than everyone else.
HB Chris Johnson – Titans – 85 to 86 – Has flourished playing behind an excellent line. We’ll see what he’s got in the playoffs.
WR Justin Gage – Titans – 81 to 83 – Played big in games where the Titans had to pass the ball.
CB Cedric Griffin – Vikings – 83 to 85 – Was bad the first half of the season, but the last half and playoff game was the best corner the Vikings had.
WR Bernard Berrian – Vikings – 85 to 86 – Lead the league in YPC in a bad passing offense.
Ratings Down
CB Charles Tillman – Bears – 92 to 90 – Took a beating by opposing WR’s down the stretch.
LT Levi Jones – Bengals – 85 to 82 – Was pretty bad in pass blocking before ending up on IR.
LT Jason Peters – Bills – 96 to 94 – Made the Pro Bowl. Gave up a league high sacks at the LT position.
CB Dre Bly – Broncos – 89 to 87 – Was awful in Denver this season with no pass rush.
DE Elvis Dumervil – Broncos – 87 to 85 – Offered no pass rush in Denver this year.
HB LaDainian Tomlinson – Chargers – 99 to 97 – Closed out his 8th season with his lowest yards (1,110) and second lowest TD total (11). Averaging 4.4 YPC for his career with 126 TD’s.
WR Marvin Harrison – Colts – 92 to 89 – Is a shadow of his old self. Looks slow and can’t beat press coverage anymore (he still gets deep because corners underestimate him).
HB Joseph Addai – Colts – 91 to 90 – A bad and dinged up season this year for Indy. The health of the offensive line was a big factor.
WR Terrell Owens – Cowboys – 98 to 96 – The party is over. A 35 year old receiver who doesn’t get open anymore won’t be given such leeway.
WR Roy Williams – Cowboys – 92 to 91 – Was not able to get open in Dallas.
FS Reggie Nelson – Jaguars – 92 to 89 – Suffered from Sophomore slump and injuries. Was beaten several times very badly and had few INT’s to show for his gambling and lack of physicality.
QB Brett Favre – Jets – 94 to 89 – Played the Jets out of the playoffs. While guys like Leon Washington were winning the Jets games, Brett was losing them and keeping them out of games.
TE Ben Watson – Patriots – 87 to 84 – Was on the field a ton, but not part of Matt Cassel’s plan.
G Jacob Bell – Rams – 92 to 88 – A big bust acquired by the Rams in the offseason. Didn’t do much.
WR Torry Holt – Rams – 93 to 92 – Looks to be out of St. Louis and its time. No longer an elite #1 WR.
DE Jason Taylor – Redskins – 97 to 96 – Was banged up all season and didn’t do much, although looked better at the end of the season.
DE Andre Carter – Redskins – 88 to 87 – Combined with Jason Taylor to underachieve at the end position.
DE Will Smith – Saints – 90 to 89 – Did nothing except water pills this season in New Orleans.
TE Jeremy Shockey – Saints – 93 to 91 – Is a shell of his former self and not worth the crap that seems to follow him.
CB Marcus Trufant – Seahawks – 93 to 91 – Had an awful year this year after a very good one last season.
C Matt Birk – Vikings – 93 to 90 – No longer an elite Center and likely out of Minnesota.
S Darren Sharper – Vikings – 90 to 88 – Hasn’t been the same and probably will be phased out of Minnesota. Can still start somewhere but isn’t the player he was.
January 10, 2009 at 12:05 pm
ok i hope they re evaluate the play of all players, or at least all starters. cuz of course its playoff season and we (the niners) are getting no love in madden or updates, byut at least soon make shaun hill jason hill issac bruce josh morgan go up along with our D like takeo spikes did great and parys harralson, just hard to play when i use only the niners and i throw to my slow ass recievers with my underated 78 QB shaun hill and itm akes him throw it OB… just hire people to do the roster updates!!!! i will do it for dam free common ill be fair lol. BS….
Last time our season ends in December baby!
January 10, 2009 at 12:10 pm
Go niners!!!!!! Cowgirls suck.. so do the ravens….. this weekends game of ravens vs titans might come out to be the most boring game in nfl history.. unless you like 2-0 games
January 10, 2009 at 12:15 pm
ya lions are awesome….
January 11, 2009 at 4:32 am
OK WHAT HAPPENS OF HES A BUST
January 11, 2009 at 5:58 am
cause the update looks pretty much up to date
January 11, 2009 at 6:38 am
I agree
January 11, 2009 at 9:26 am
Once again Ed Reed and the Dblock Defense prove why theyre the best at what they do, just a little screwed up the chargers get homefield advantage next week in the afc championship with an 8-8 record…flacco showed a lot of poise today, unfortunately EA has released an official statement today declaring that baltimores defense is so good they will only boost flacco 1 point if he wins the superbowl although it made more sense at the end of the statement when it was signed by ea's new co-owner jerry jones…
January 15, 2009 at 9:48 am
Why am I not surprised to see Ken with his stupid opinions? Looks like you were far off with that prediction of his Sunday's AFC Championship game.
Flacco didn't do shit. Read his stats over again…Did you even watch the game?The guy couldn't get anything done. He did have one nice bomb to Mason though. The Ravens only won because of the Titans screwing themselves over with turnovers…not to mention horrible missed calls. (Mainly that delay of game)
That "Dblock Defense" sure was getting torn up…until Johnson got hurt…it was all downhill from there.
Once again,another inaccurate,pointless post by Ken.
January 11, 2009 at 10:11 am
jason avant needs a serious update. ea has his speed at 87 that rediculious. he runs amazing routes and is faster than an 87. hes become mcnabbs security blanket when hes on the field. hes way better than a 77
January 11, 2009 at 11:03 am
Kris again you have a point. The eagles are severely underrated. That defense is shutdown. They don't allow anything. The giants had all of their yards off of 2 plays. McNabb is playing at a high level and hopefully Avant's catch can make us forget about Freddie"No Hands" 4th and 26 ( he needs to go someplace hide and never show his face). The Eagles are just rolling and they are playing the best ball in the NFL right now 2 games to go. E A G L E S, EAGLES!
Also that safety call on McNabb was bogus. The refs gave NY a quick 2 points and the ball on that BS call. His arm was coming forward and he got hit when he threw it, How many intentional grounding throws has P. Rivers thrown in the last 2 games? He never gets called for one in fact he just threw another ball into the ground as I'm writing this. The Eagles offensive line pass protection should be increase along with McNabb, D. JAckson, J, Avant, S. Bradley, Bunkley, Patterson, Mikell and Samuel. In fact Samuel should be a 99 pure shutdown corner. That guy's play is bananas as he is the best corner in the game sorry C.Bailey but like Biggie said "your reign on the top was short like leprechauns."
January 12, 2009 at 1:51 am
WOW I FOUND AN EAGLE BROTHER…LOL. man ur so right all those guys should go up and ppl forget that oour pro bowl RG who just happens to be the best gaurd in football is out. and we still have fantastic pass protection. i say this to make the point that none of our linemen should be rated any lower than 80. and dont u think that gocong needs a major boost along with akeem jordan? those guys played great. and asante is the best corner in the game!
January 12, 2009 at 3:02 am
Avant is Mr. Third Down. he should really be rated higher than Reggie Clown.
January 11, 2009 at 10:30 am
ryan clady is the best rookie this yr in the nfl
January 11, 2009 at 11:05 am
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA….
I think every team prefers him and not Matt Ryan (best rookie QB since Dan Marino), Chris Johnson, Joe Flacco.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
January 15, 2009 at 9:52 am
Umm..I don't remember Marino,Flacco, or Matt Ryan ever leading his team to 15 straight wins(all on his first start in week two) plus a win in the playoffs (to only be screwed over in the AFC Championship) like Roethlisberger did. There's no rookie QB like Big Ben ever was…from what I remember.
January 11, 2009 at 12:59 pm
to all you flacco haters he his team in the afc championship
January 12, 2009 at 1:06 am
McNabb and the eagles need to show me a little more to justify a ratings increase. It looks as though they are playing off of luck instead of skills like the Cowboys. When I see the Cowboys I see a legendary team who suffered key injuries at the wrongs times when I see the eagle I see a mediocre team that was completely healthy all year and barely gets wins. He is a quick game you can play look at Philly and tell me which position any position that they are better than the cowboys. QB? WR? TE? Whoever it doesn't matter the Cowboys are stronger at every position hands down they just got unlucky this year with injuires.
January 12, 2009 at 2:03 am
the eagles had no injuries right??????????? RG shawn andrews(the best RG in football), WR kevin curtis(missed 8 gms), RB brian westbrook (hes playin fucked up and missed three games), reggie brown(same as curtis he missed first 8 gms)
ok now ill play ur little game_____
RB westbrook > barber
QB mcnabb(whos in the playoffs) > romo(whos not)
FSdawkins > hamlin
SSquintin mikell > roy or davis either one hes better than
CBasante and sheldon > newman and henry
OTrunyan and tre thomas > columbo and flozell(the human penalty flag)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!WE WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! u idiot
January 12, 2009 at 2:54 am
OK lets start with Westbrook. He best game in the past 5 games is 53 yards so I give the edge to Barber, F. Jones and T. Choice. McNabb vs Romo, who has the higher passer rating has a high winning percentage and plays with more pressure? I give that to Romo by a mile. He's better in the pocket and had a better season with a broken hand while McNabb was completely healthy. Dawkins vs Hamlin are you kidding me? How old is Dawkins slow self? The reason they blitz him so much is because he can not cover worth a darn. Hamlin has more speed and play making ability. Quinin Mikell vs R. Williams and K. Davis. I say pretty even on that one. R. Williams is a one trick pony and K. Davis is a special teamer but guess what so is Q. mikell. He has one okay season and you are ready to put him in the HOF lol. Ask Q. Mikell if he still has B. Jacobs footprint on his chest. As for the corners Newmans is the best tied with C. Bailey. Absolute shutdown corner PLAYING MAN TO MAN. Noticed how I had to put that in there because what people do not know is that A. Samuel doesn't play man to man he plays ZONE another one trick pony. The 2 tackles are pretty even but i give the nod to Dallas because they not only pass block better like Tra and Runyan they actually push on running plays. So there you have it KRIS Dallas is better at every position except of SS where I give it an even rating
January 12, 2009 at 6:14 am
OK I WANT WANT PPL TO READ THIS SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!! TELL THIS DUMBASS HOW STUPID AND BITTER HE SOUNDS WITH THIS BULLSHIT RESPONSE TO WHAT I WROTE
January 12, 2009 at 6:28 am
well atleast someone else sees that dallas and the eagles have two of the worst strong safeties in the league and again i completely agree that it is difficult to see whos better but i think id give the edge to mikell just barely because he doesnt get 15 yd penalties when/if he makes a tackle. westbrooks better than barber (19th) jones (IR) and t choice (bust) put together hes a little worse than portis in straight running technique but a lil better in the pass catching dept, definetetly a top 5 back, as apossed to the backfield by parolee that dallas employs. Dawkins is the 2nd best free safety in the league behind Ed Reed and as i have maintained for a few weeks should be a 95-97. Finally santanna moss loves the most overrated corner in football, terrance newman had to where a moss jersey the monday after santana had his 6th straight 100 yard game against him
ps quintin mikell made the allpro team in place of any other above average to excellent safeties (dawkins, horton, bigby) but i cant say im shocked its the same guys who didnt put rivers in a probowl…
January 12, 2009 at 7:00 am
WOW! ken u just shocked me with the fair statements u made. thank u. i still hate u tho. lol. but y dont u think think quintin mikell is a great safety? do u kno him personaly or somethin? the guy is great and had an amazing season. again, thanks
January 12, 2009 at 10:15 am
your welcome kind of i guess, ive had the displeasure of watching him play for the last 3 seasons, at least when considine did it i could laugh when hed blow the coverage or a tackle but when this guy does the exact same things, like portis juking him out of his shoes, he gets voted on the all pro team im all for players progressing but ive seen no progression from the new king of special teamers, id be just as pissed if reed doughty made the probowl, or more based in reality chris "i cant pick up a simple blitz" samuels making the probowl
January 15, 2009 at 9:56 am
Hilarious how you don't mention Polamalu… who AGAIN is better than Reed. Remember what i told you about him not being a good tackler? It was on EPN a few days ago ironically after I told you a few days before that about his tackling…I thought to myself..I really hope Ken's watching this. Get over yourself and your hate for the Steelers bitch.
January 16, 2009 at 11:19 pm
man youre an angry one aintcha? i didnt mention polamalu because i was talking about free safeties, besides i prove a more poignant point by comparing him to the best safety in the league not the 2nd best…
January 12, 2009 at 7:01 am
o i forget to mention that or entire d line is better too my bad
January 12, 2009 at 10:29 am
you also forgot cornerbacks, special teams, half backs (fullback too), linebackers, quarterbacks and offensive line pretty much everything execpt tight ends in which case it is a tie because there is no depth behind witten (so 90+702=80) and the eagles have 2 starting caliber tight ends (85+80/2=82ish), which by the way kris where the hell is you bitching and moaning about celek the guy has played like hes elite for 5-6 weeks now and you pick avant over him! i swear you pick every guy on that team that i dont think deserves an upgrade and miss most of the ones that i think do its kinda funny actually…
January 12, 2009 at 6:03 am
I already discussed cornerbacks, Dallas has the edge because they play MAN TO MAN. Halfback? Dallas has 3 Philly has 1 with two bad knees. Fullback? Dallas has an actual fullback on the roster. Philly has an defensive tackle trying to play fullback (hasn't anyone notice how hard it is for the eagles to convert 3rd or 4th and 1). Tight End? I'll rate this but everybody already knows that it's Dallas by a landslide. On a scale of 1-1000 Dallas TE's are about an 98 Witten is a beast and Bennet is an upcomer just stuck behind the best TE not named Gonzales. Philly TE's L. J Smith and Celek are about an 5. Can you possibly have a worse TE? LJ can not catch, block, run good routes, or run after the catch. He is another reason Philly can not convert on 3rd or 4th and short. The only reason I'm giving Philly a 5 is because I gave Celek a 10. At least he can make positive plays, not much though but something at least. Special Teams? Dallas wins this one too. How many times would F. Jones have taken it to the house if he were healthy? probably about 4 or 5 x's. So there you have it Ken and Kris Dallas is superb in every way. Do you really want to continue on? Kicker? Dallas. Punter? Dallas. Center? Dallas. Middle LB? Dallas Outside LB's? Dallas. Special Teams Gunner? Well maybe the eagles have a better special teams gunner as I do not know who they are on either team. So maybe the eagles do have one position they are better. I will have to review the tape. I'll get back to you in a few days to let you know my findings on that one.
January 16, 2009 at 11:03 pm
wow you can actually do some basic math, congrats your now officially the smartest cowboys fan on the planet, true thats not saying much but i digress, dallas has 3 average halfbacks philly has 1 all star and 2 average halfbacks that dept definetely goes to philly, you cant argue against it so dont bother, its just the way things are, tight ends yea wittens the second best tight end in the nfc so naturally they got a leg up there bennet has been progressing but hes average at best hell make an improvement moving into next year but for now philly has 2 starting calliber tight ends so its a tough call but seeing as witten was injured all year i barely give it to philly, Special teams im not giving you cus your fantasizing about a healthy felix jones, sadly im gonna use your question back atcha to prove why phillys better, how many times did desean jackson run it back? 4-5? kicker david akers missed like 2 on the year, and he doesnt play indoors, so phillys better there, punter, phillys lasted more than 4 weeks so better there too, center i dont care so much about but guards phillys got u beat on starters and depth todd herrimans is one of the best in the biz, so again that goes to philly, LB corps? philly again, sorry Mr EA but you cant knock the number one D in the NFC…i hope the tape enlightened you as to how bad dallas really is, you should make like pacman an jumpship bro…
January 12, 2009 at 8:32 am
ken…. i dont "bitch" about our te's because they cant catch or block. when they can consistently catch 1 and 2 yd passes then maybe i will start "bitchin" about an update.
January 16, 2009 at 11:26 pm
dude im just saying i can only remember 2 passes celeks dropped in 4 weeks, thats pretty damn good and hes also has a td streak going…
January 12, 2009 at 2:43 am
ok i jus had to say something lol A-rod good his rating went up and Matt Cassel congrats love both of those QBs hope Cassel gets to detroit with CJ next year, or stay with pats if Brady is guaranteed not ready but c'mon jabar gaffney no rating up he was part of Cassels plan
January 12, 2009 at 6:16 am
i liked where u were going but u completely just derailed me with the gaffney statement
January 12, 2009 at 10:32 am
^loves the pats
jabar will not get an upgrade hes fine as is, cmon seriously you need someone else with welker moss and washington? makes me wish theyd kept chad jackson…
January 12, 2009 at 5:52 am
Wow. are all you guys dating. yall talk to each other more than i talk to my girl. lets start of, Cowbabies suck. highly overated. they have the most talent and cant do anything. on paper they are the better than the eagles, yea, but perception is reality. they have not done anything worth braging rights since emmit and troy. old people like to call that the glory days. the thing about tony is that hes homo. the guy chokes, i mean you talkin bout him like hes a god. so do you wanna blow him cuz his passer ratin is better than Dmac. boy u sound like a rookie fan. ratin has nothin to do with the game if ur not playin it. drew brees alomst broke one of the best qb records of all time, but hes not playin this weekend. stat doesnt matter anymore, moving on to next year. please for the sake of u not makin the cowboys look worse than they truly are, shut the fuck up. u sound like an idiot. so roll over of tony cock and take a nap you waste of life mr ea.
January 12, 2009 at 6:19 am
Tony Romo and Donovan McNabb have the same amount of championships which is 0. So I had to go by the statistics. Romo has an 94.7 career passer rating to McNabb's 85.9 rating. When it comes to TD's Romo had more TD's missing 3 games and playing with a broken hand than a healthy McNabb this season.Romo's record as a starter the past 3 years is: 8-5; 13-3; 7-5 while McNabb's is: 5-5; 8-8; 9-6-1 for a total of 28-13 for Romo and 22-19-1 for McNabb. So there you go the stats don't lie Romo just better. You can not even compare McNabb to Brad Johnson. Brad Johnson had a better career and has a Super Bowl ring. Cowboys are just better all the way around case closed.
January 12, 2009 at 8:24 am
I thought Madded is based on the season you had or have. If I am right will Tom Brady be rated high or low. Adam Jones was lowerd cause he missex a full season. I hope Tom Brady get the same treatment
January 12, 2009 at 11:43 am
ya tom brady didnt have a say in how he played… pacman just got burned all day… thats why you cant decease the guy to a 98 or lower… he is the man and i am a niner fan so dont hate…. i would doubt seeing his injury go down tho haha
January 13, 2009 at 10:26 am
Who cares y Adam or Brady miised the season it happend. They should get the same treatment. This is Madden NFL. If you miss a season for any reason that hurts you in the NFL. If anything Adam could workout and keep in some shape. Braby can only rehab. Stop letting personal things affect how you rate people on madden!!
January 12, 2009 at 8:01 am
Just an update fellas. There will be 2 more updates and the final teams will all get increases. Also to explain the increases on players who are not in the playoffs that get a upgrade, the reason is to look at the season as a whole and adjust the players according to their 2008 season production. So expect to see your Eagles Kris get a good upgrade. If your eagles make the Superbowl Kris, your eagles will be close to on par with the most talented team ever created the Dallas Cowboys.
January 12, 2009 at 8:28 am
romo also has the best recieving core outside of new england and still isnt in the playoffs
January 13, 2009 at 4:19 am
He missed 3 games where they went 1-2 and was playing with a broken hand the rest of the way He still had a great season though so he may get a ratings boost
January 13, 2009 at 6:11 am
he should get a negative boost if that is what you meant. tony romo is the next danny white. he will never be able to make dallas a champion. and there is a big difference between romo and mcnabb; mcnabb actually has a set of balls.
January 16, 2009 at 11:28 pm
and an NFC championship ring, but comparably i was gonna say archie manning is comparable to romo but great danny white pull…
January 12, 2009 at 9:20 am
who the hell is this Mr.EA Sports? sounds like a complete Dallas homer, and a dumbass
January 13, 2009 at 3:27 am
I'm the guy your mama was ready to do the jump off for So-So
January 13, 2009 at 10:22 am
You don't work for EA. You are some clown on this blog being someone he wish he was. Grow up MR. EA sports. Go out get a job or finsh school.
January 12, 2009 at 11:42 am
these are not every single one of the ratings that got changed right… cuz there has to be a couple niners in here…. anybody confirm any niner love…?
January 12, 2009 at 12:07 pm
TO STEEL CURTAIN:
MY HUMBLEST APOLOGIES FOR OVERLOOKING THE STEELERS BEING IN THE AFC CHAMPIONSHIP, when i picked the chargers i thought they could overcome having norv turner being their coach, i couldnt have been more wrong…
January 15, 2009 at 10:01 am
Wow…i didn't see that coming…I saw this right after I talked some more smack to some of your other posts lol. Apologies are accepted though bro.
January 13, 2009 at 11:36 am
I got a job and have completed my B. A. in Business as in none of yours. No really I have an computer science degree from UCLA and do work in some capacity with video games(maybe not EA but I'll never tell) so I do know some tidbits you and your fellow Maddenetes may not know. Anything else Pharoh? Ok now you may sit in the corner with your special hat.
January 14, 2009 at 10:24 am
Y are you such an clown. With a B.A. Someone would think you are a man. More than half the idots on this site are kids who talk trash on players or other people, cause they would never do that shit in real life. All I am saing dont add to that crap. Let punks be clowns
January 13, 2009 at 12:20 pm
in the next madden 2010 their should be a online superstar mode were people can fight for positions and play as a team on the road to the superbowl
January 15, 2009 at 8:32 am
that would be awsome!!!!! but for a team like EA thats pretty much impossible. hell they lied about having an online franchise mode. they pretty much suck
p.s. EA im still a little scared by not being able to play franchise mode online
January 14, 2009 at 11:33 am
Raiders best WR’s are Johnnie Lee Higgins (74) and Chaz Schilens (67), the starters by the end of the season.
Javon Walker (83), Ronald Curry (76) and Ashley Lelie (75) all have better ratings than JLH and Chaz, which is not fair since both outplayed them all.
JaMarcus Russell was 6 TD’s 2 INT’s and 88+ rating over the last 6 games, where Oakland was 3-3 after beating Houston at home and Tampa Bay and Denver on the road. 75 overall for JaMarcus is too low, and 76 in accuracy is laughable.
January 16, 2009 at 11:33 pm
ok i give you the recievers higgins should be no higher than an 81 until santanna moss gets boosted from 84 just to give you a comparable player, russel might get plus 1 or 2 points but no more because you need to come to grips with the fact that hes the next david carr great arm, no awr, cant read a D, horrible pocket presence, id keep going but im not trying to dis your boy just present a counter opinion
January 18, 2009 at 8:09 am
correction moss is an 88 which is still undercutting him but higgins should be about 85 comparably
January 15, 2009 at 2:48 am
LT still has is it he never got going after the foot injury and couldn't push off or drive into people to finish runs he will be strong next year. Fin's Fan how can you call RavEn's (notice the E) fan's sutch ignorrant bitches when you can't even spell it's such ignorant bitches you seem ignorant. Dude you had four spelling errors in a 23 word sentence with a huge grammer mistake!!! Yes they should bounce Flacco up a little I mean dude held his team down and has them in the AFC championship maybe an 80?
January 19, 2009 at 7:51 am
Heyyyyyy Ken where are ya bro? What was all that talk about Reed being better than Polamalu? And what else did you say? Better at returning touchdowns? Uhh yeah, which is why Reed had NO picks and NO touchdowns when he played against the team you talked shit about.. The comparison has been made official now that the two teams played. Polamalu did exactly what you praised Reed for. Reed did NOTHING. As for all you other Steelers haters, get over yourself. As for everyone who wanted us to win, thanks for the support.
As for you people asking for Flacco updates…uhh…82 is too high after we showed you the real Flacco. CRUMBLING under pressure. 3 picks?? The DEFENSE kept you close…as usual. Not Flacco.
Lastly, HOW BOUT THEM STEELERS?!
January 19, 2009 at 7:04 pm
Maybe Flacco isnt that bad… maybe he went againts a very elite D as a rookie. You do know In superbowl 40 Rothlisberger had the worst qb rating of any QB who has played in a superbowl. But they won and made plays.
January 20, 2009 at 9:43 pm
Flacco is good but he is far from great. He did what trent dilfer did for the ravens. Do anyone know his playoff stats? I am willing to bet they a horrible. Who cares if he had no int the first two games he had no td
January 15, 2009 at 9:24 am
I won't be a hypocrate. If it weren't for the Steelers D this year, our team would be nowhere. Our o-line is garbage.I'll give the line credit though in that game against the Chargers; they really stepped up.
January 15, 2009 at 9:28 am
*they're
January 15, 2009 at 9:57 am
(to Ken)
January 19, 2009 at 7:52 am
Btw…Sorry Kris. Steelers-Cardinals Super Bowl.
January 19, 2009 at 7:53 am
And I went too far with the bitch comment in that post. Sorry. I didn't see your apology later on in the other posts.
January 23, 2009 at 9:48 pm
its cool, as far as ed reed not picking off Ben, i said i hated ben not that he was romo like in his ball handling, also kudos to the offensive coordinator, pretty much every (id say 90-95%) throw was on the opposite side of the field as ed reed which is incredibly smart! and just a reminder im a skins fan not ravens so im not overly hyped on flacco but 82 is too low. Remember ratings should be comparable so if the worst qb in the league (trent edwards, i know its subjective but i hate that guy) is an 85 flacco should fall in the 83-86 range 83 imho being fair…also id like to say theres a reason cam cameron went 1-15, when you tell your qb to attack polamalu (see the spelling lessons took) instead of ryan "im not good enough to start for the skins" clark chances are you wont win that game
January 22, 2009 at 12:29 am
how are you guys trying to ask for upgrades on sub par wrs like higgins when desean jackson is an 81 and had an awesome rookie season. wrs like steve smith of the giants eddie royal and i know there are a few more that are rated higher then d jax and it doesnt make sense. smith is an 84/85 right now and his rookie season he did wat 60 yards in the regular season. this year he had like 560 and 1 td. desean as a rookie posted 900 plus in the regular season and almost 300 in the post season and hes only an 81 come on now. EA has alot of dumb ratings in madden that mkae no sense at all, like pierce the mlb for the giants having 85 speed with 87 acc. the guy is slow period. the eagles better get a huge upgrade on the next roster update for completely beating dallas, winning on the road in the playoffs against min and in the meadowlands. and to put all the mcnabb and romo whos better talk to end. give mcnabb curtis the whole season or one true #1 wr and see wat kind of numbers he puts up again. btw eli manning shouldnt have accurate qb are you kidding me, the loss of plax really hurt hes throwing off his back foot accuarcy.
January 26, 2009 at 2:56 am
Brandon Jacobs should be no lower then a 94 overall
February 20, 2009 at 1:30 am
Donavon Mcnabb should be to a 94 because he lead the eagles to the NFC championship