Madden 10 vs 09 Screenshot Comparison

by
Posted August 3rd, 2009 at 1:02 pm

m100803

EA Sports has posted up a screenshot comparison with side-by-side images from Madden 10 vs Madden 09. Not only are the shots taken from gameplay but also aspects such as the menus and play call screen. It is easy to overlook what a drastic upgrade the game has received graphically, but seeing similar shots from 09 really makes the improvements obvious. The lighting, depth of field, player models, and cleaner on-field display really stand out.

Check out all the screens here and leave your thoughts in the comments!

Tags:
  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

    Here are the official numbers darkheath. Now you know Mo Diddley can back up what he claims. I did a little research and found comparable numbers halfway through with Madden 04 and 2K5 but the final numbers are staggering

    Madden 04 game sales=5.91 million copies
    @ $50 bucks=295.5 Million

    NFL 2K game sales=3.45 million copies
    @ $20 bucks=69 million

    Now if that isn't killing the competition then you tell me what is?

    *this is only taking into consideration the top 2 platforms (PS2 & XBOX) at that time

    Mo Diddley the factual expert!

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

    Here are the official numbers darkheath. Now you know Mo Diddley can back up what he claims. I did a little research and found comparable numbers halfway through with Madden 04 and 2K5 but the final numbers are staggering

    Madden 04 game sales=5.91 million copies
    @ $50 bucks=295.5 Million

    NFL 2K game sales=3.45 million copies
    @ $20 bucks=69 million

    Now if that isn't killing the competition then you tell me what is?

    *this is only taking into consideration the top 2 platforms (PS2 & XBOX) at that time

    Mo Diddley the factual expert!he updates for MLB the Show 09?

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/darkheath darkheath

    I played that game over 400 hours. I would have dropped $100 for it. It was easily worth it. Just because things like caviar have a high price tag doesn't mean it tastes good. Don't let the price fool ya, kid.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

    Here are the official numbers darkheath. Now you know Mo Diddley can back up what he claims. I did a little research and found comparable numbers halfway through with Madden 04 and 2K5 but the final numbers are staggering

    Madden 04 game sales=5.91 million copies
    @ $50 bucks=295.5 Million

    NFL 2K game sales=3.45 million copies
    @ $20 bucks=69 million

    Now if that isn't killing the competition then you tell me what is?

    *this is only taking into consideration the top 2 platforms (PS2 & XBOX) at that time

    Mo Diddley the factual expert!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/darkheath darkheath

    The worse thing about NFL 2k5 was that TO was on the cover. ;-)

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/darkheath darkheath

    The worse thing about NFL 2k5 was that TO was on the cover. ;-)

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Halosniper52 Halosniper52

    I still like 09's play calling screen SO MUCH better than 10. Also I hate that you can't sub in play type now, just formations sucks. Overall tho 10's alot better really notice it in the faces of the players.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

      I agree they shouldn't have changed the play calling, but I think they wanted to feature some of the new shots of coaches on the sidelines and injured players riding the bike and so on. It shouldn't be that hard to get used to eventually.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Halosniper52 Halosniper52

    I still like 09's play calling screen SO MUCH better than 10. Also I hate that you can't sub in play type now, just formations sucks. Overall tho 10's alot better really notice it in the faces of the players.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

      I agree they shouldn't have changed the play calling, but I think they wanted to feature some of the new shots of coaches on the sidelines and injured players riding the bike and so on. It shouldn't be that hard to get used to eventually.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

    Mo Diddley will agree with you there darkheath as Madden 06 IMO was the best Madden to ever come out (of course barring Madden 10). 06 had something they have yet to duplicate…..personalities. I wish they would go back to that.

    Mo Diddley the peaceful resolution-ist!<<<okay so i made up that word but you know what I mean

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/darkheath darkheath

      Yes.. I loved the newspapers and the Bruno show. yes… personality.____

      darkheath says… you don't annoy me anymore.

      I wasn't looking for a fight anyway.

      cheers.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

    Mo Diddley will agree with you there darkheath as Madden 06 IMO was the best Madden to ever come out (of course barring Madden 10). 06 had something they have yet to duplicate…..personalities. I wish they would go back to that.

    Mo Diddley the peaceful resolution-ist!<<<okay so i made up that word but you know what I mean

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/darkheath darkheath

      Yes.. I loved the newspapers and the Bruno show. yes… personality.____

      darkheath says… you don't annoy me anymore.

      I wasn't looking for a fight anyway.

      cheers.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/acreyman acreyman

    MUCH BETTER! they got rid of that "fog" to make things look further away. all that did was annoy the crap out of me. I complained alot when I first saw that because the only time things look foggy at a game is when the weather is bad or fireworks just went off. this looks MUCH clearer now and way better than it used to. The helmets are nice and shiney and there is a hint of metalic in the paint even from a distance. NICE!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/acreyman acreyman

    MUCH BETTER! they got rid of that "fog" to make things look further away. all that did was annoy the crap out of me. I complained alot when I first saw that because the only time things look foggy at a game is when the weather is bad or fireworks just went off. this looks MUCH clearer now and way better than it used to. The helmets are nice and shiney and there is a hint of metalic in the paint even from a distance. NICE!

  • ryan

    hey pasta have you seen this…?

    https://subs.timeinc.net/SI/si_madden09.jhtml?exp

    madden 10 is free if you become a si member

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

      This is a scam. I checked with Sports Illustrated and they said that they were not doing any such promotion

      Mo Diddley the People's Champ!

      • ACREYMAN

        yeah dont throw your CC info down on this.

      • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/sroeland sroeland

        Really? Because it is listed on SI.com at the top…so I doubt that the folks at Sports Illustrated would post a scam on their own Web site.

        <a href="http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/” target=”_blank”>http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/

        Look at the upper left of the screen. "Get EA SPORTS Madden 10 Video Game FREE!"

        Unless of course, when you say scam, you are referring to SI's reluctance to allow you to cancel your subscription after one year. And then after cancelling, they continue to charge your credit card…

  • ryan

    hey pasta have you seen this…?

    https://subs.timeinc.net/SI/si_madden09.jhtml?exp

    madden 10 is free if you become a si member

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Mo_Diddley Mo_Diddley

      This is a scam. I checked with Sports Illustrated and they said that they were not doing any such promotion

      Mo Diddley the People's Champ!

      • ACREYMAN

        yeah dont throw your CC info down on this.

      • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/sroeland sroeland

        Really? Because it is listed on SI.com at the top…so I doubt that the folks at Sports Illustrated would post a scam on their own Web site.

        <a href="http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/” target=”_blank”>http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/

        Look at the upper left of the screen. "Get EA SPORTS Madden 10 Video Game FREE!"

        Unless of course, when you say scam, you are referring to SI's reluctance to allow you to cancel your subscription after one year. And then after cancelling, they continue to charge your credit card…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000059736340 Jesse Anderson

    Eh, it looks a little better, but that could just be some photoshopping of 09 to make things look whitewashed. The depth of field is cool, and the player models are a lot better.

    But truthfully, unless you're watching a replay, the player models didn't have to improve that much. Nice, but not a deal sealer for me. It's all in the gameplay.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000059736340 Jesse Anderson

    Eh, it looks a little better, but that could just be some photoshopping of 09 to make things look whitewashed. The depth of field is cool, and the player models are a lot better.

    But truthfully, unless you're watching a replay, the player models didn't have to improve that much. Nice, but not a deal sealer for me. It's all in the gameplay.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/DrLogic DrLogic

    Next year they need to put the effort they spend on graphical updates toward updating their presentation and fleshing out Online Dynasty. Gameplay and graphics, while not perfect, are more than good enough. Presentation which has marginally improved over the last 5 years has always been an afterthought for EA across the board. If they didn’t touch the graphics and only focused on online gaming and immersive presentation, Madden 11 would be undeniable.

    Madden 10 is the first step in the right direction, but will inevitably lack immersion and depth as many of EA's titles do. Hopefully EA wises up to this issue and makes the proper adjustments for Madden 11.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/DrLogic DrLogic

    Next year they need to put the effort they spend on graphical updates toward updating their presentation and fleshing out Online Dynasty. Gameplay and graphics, while not perfect, are more than good enough. Presentation which has marginally improved over the last 5 years has always been an afterthought for EA across the board. If they didn’t touch the graphics and only focused on online gaming and immersive presentation, Madden 11 would be undeniable.

    Madden 10 is the first step in the right direction, but will inevitably lack immersion and depth as many of EA's titles do. Hopefully EA wises up to this issue and makes the proper adjustments for Madden 11.

  • boobie smoove

    damn warners face looks looks crap in 09

  • boobie smoove

    damn warners face looks looks crap in 09

  • SwiftyCG

    WAY WAY WAY BETTER can't wait!

  • SwiftyCG

    WAY WAY WAY BETTER can't wait!

  • sean

    im not sure i like the new play calling

  • sean

    im not sure i like the new play calling

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    C'mon man we all know Mo isn't the most intelligent person on here but you don't need to be using his name and sayin that shit on every thread. Get an account and say make a legit comment if you got something to say.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    C'mon man we all know Mo isn't the sanest person on here but you don't need to be using his name and sayin that shit on every thread. Get an account and say make a legit comment if you got something to say.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rezluk Rezluk

      i agree

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    C'mon man we all know Mo isn't the most intelligent person on here but you don't need to be using his name and sayin that shit on every thread. Get an account and say make a legit comment if you got something to say.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    C'mon man we all know Mo isn't the sanest person on here but you don't need to be using his name and sayin that shit on every thread. Get an account and say make a legit comment if you got something to say.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rezluk Rezluk

      i agree

  • JudgeBrown

    Mo Diddley, you sure are spending a lot of time posting here. Did you lose your cashier position at McDonalds?

  • JudgeBrown

    Mo Diddley, you sure are spending a lot of time posting here. Did you lose your cashier position at McDonalds?

  • Vizen

    I still like 09's playcalling screen better…

  • Vizen

    I still like 09's playcalling screen better…

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Willy2535 Willy2535

    theyve stated that they went through and made all the players look authentic with their gear that they wear, but from the Seahawks videos that ive seen i picked out a number of players who still had the wrong equipment, hopefully its adressed wen it comes out, coz thats one of the little things that wen done right makes the game look better

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Willy2535 Willy2535

    theyve stated that they went through and made all the players look authentic with their gear that they wear, but from the Seahawks videos that ive seen i picked out a number of players who still had the wrong equipment, hopefully its adressed wen it comes out, coz thats one of the little things that wen done right makes the game look better

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/joetm joetm

    nice post

    the only thing i noticed on the screenshots was the lighting, the lighting in madden 10 is so much better

    Stewart B. was a big loss :( , first dawkins and now him, hopefully someone steps up

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/joetm joetm

    nice post

    the only thing i noticed on the screenshots was the lighting, the lighting in madden 10 is so much better

    Stewart B. was a big loss :( , first dawkins and now him, hopefully someone steps up

  • Waltman

    I bet EA Sports would find it alot harder to be compared to another actual competing football game like 2K then having Madden 10 compared to their own shit game from last year. Just another reason they monopolized the market like they did, if not you'd be comparing Madden 10 screenshots with NFL 2k10 right now

  • Waltman

    I bet EA Sports would find it alot harder to be compared to another actual competing football game like 2K then having Madden 10 compared to their own shit game from last year. Just another reason they monopolized the market like they did, if not you'd be comparing Madden 10 screenshots with NFL 2k10 right now

  • Madden History

    2007 – NFL becomes more hands on and touchy with overseeing aspects of game – No tattoos, less violent hits, less fun celebrations, other uniform related issues

    2007-2008- Two of the worst editions in the series history receive top reviews and awards from various gaming publications, no doubt creating a sense of complacency within EA Sports. These near perfect ratings also may have caused an incentive for the NFL to renew the exclusivity license even further, which they did until 2012.

    2008-2009 – After nearly 5 years of Madden only football gaming, the bar becomes greatly lowered, and an enormously flawed Madden 09 gets a positive reception. 9’s and 10’s mysteriously fly around for a game that has little to no concept of weight detection, broken sliders, noticeable player abilities or tendencies, and freezing bugs, among other issues. Where we see the birth of the terms “Robo QB”, “Suction Blocking” and Phonebooth Tackling” to describe soley Next Gen Madden’s issues.

  • Madden History

    2006 – Much hoopla gets made about EA Sports acquiring the ESPN license, which they then end up doing absolutely nothing of note with to enhance the gaming experience.

    2006- David Ortiz takes charge of Madden franchise for two disastrous years that this gen Madden may never recover from due to EA’s refusal to change engine

    2006 – John Madden, original creator and namesake of Madden, is pushed out/steps down as a creative force behind Madden games.

    2006 – Popularity of online play causes EA to tweak game in accordance to its online community cheesers rather then real NFL football as had previously been the case for a decade. Despite publicly deriding and criticizing cheap online play, EA goes on to market toward these same players, even producing a TV series around them called “Madden Nation”.

  • Madden History

    Brief Timeline decline of Madden football

    2005 – Madden releases one of its most well received games in history, Madden 2005. It is regarded as the peak of Madden’s life on the Ps2 and XBOX. 2K Sports counters with the release of what will go on to be the most critically acclaimed football game of all time, NFL 2k5, which coincidentally would be 2K’s last NFL game. Times are good.

    Late 2005 – EA Sports sign an exclusive licensing deal through 2009 with the NFL and the NFLPA to give them the exclusive rights to use the NFL's teams, stadiums and players in a video game.

    2006 – EA misleads the public with a over dramatized movie trailer which was portrayed as being what Madden on the Next Gen gameplay would be like. This would turn out to be be 100% false.

  • Madden History

    Brief Timeline decline of Madden football

    2005 – Madden releases one of its most well received games in history, Madden 2005. It is regarded as the peak of Madden’s life on the Ps2 and XBOX. 2K Sports counters with the release of what will go on to be the most critically acclaimed football game of all time, NFL 2k5, which coincidentally would be 2K’s last NFL game. Times are good.

    Late 2005 – EA Sports sign an exclusive licensing deal through 2009 with the NFL and the NFLPA to give them the exclusive rights to use the NFL's teams, stadiums and players in a video game.

    2006 – EA misleads the public with a over dramatized movie trailer which was portrayed as being what Madden on the Next Gen gameplay would be like. This would turn out to be be 100% false.

  • Madden History

    2006 – Much hoopla gets made about EA Sports acquiring the ESPN license, which they then end up doing absolutely nothing of note with to enhance the gaming experience.

    2006- David Ortiz takes charge of Madden franchise for two disastrous years that this gen Madden may never recover from due to EA’s refusal to change engine

    2006 – John Madden, original creator and namesake of Madden, is pushed out/steps down as a creative force behind Madden games.

    2006 – Popularity of online play causes EA to tweak game in accordance to its online community cheesers rather then real NFL football as had previously been the case for a decade. Despite publicly deriding and criticizing cheap online play, EA goes on to market toward these same players, even producing a TV series around them called “Madden Nation”.

  • Madden History

    2007 – NFL becomes more hands on and touchy with overseeing aspects of game – No tattoos, less violent hits, less fun celebrations, other uniform related issues

    2007-2008- Two of the worst editions in the series history receive top reviews and awards from various gaming publications, no doubt creating a sense of complacency within EA Sports. These near perfect ratings also may have caused an incentive for the NFL to renew the exclusivity license even further, which they did until 2012.

    2008-2009 – After nearly 5 years of Madden only football gaming, the bar becomes greatly lowered, and an enormously flawed Madden 09 gets a positive reception. 9’s and 10’s mysteriously fly around for a game that has little to no concept of weight detection, broken sliders, noticeable player abilities or tendencies, and freezing bugs, among other issues. Where we see the birth of the terms “Robo QB”, “Suction Blocking” and Phonebooth Tackling” to describe soley Next Gen Madden’s issues.

  • Madden History

    2008-2009- David Ortiz gets the shaft, and it is announced that Madden 10 will be headed by Ian Cummings, Ian and Co. proclaim a much needed new direction for Madden, despite the “EA Marketing team” directly on the other coin praising the successes of Madden 09 financially and gameplay wise in order to market Madden 10. Despite this back to basics profession, the producers decide to stick with the original heavily criticized engine to make their improvements on top of. Early impressions of the demo showed the same problems that plauged Madden 09, not suprisingly.

    Some say 2k football would never outsell Madden, but that was 5 years ago. Consider if the great 2k Football games were available each year after year, for the past 5 awful years of Madden. Consider if consumers had a choice. It is my belief that the exact same thing that happened with 2K basketball slowly taking over the market from EA Sports NBA Live in those same 5 years, would have happened with football. Maybe someone at EA recognized this, and pushed for the exclusive license.

    • pat

      actually madden 09 was the first madden that was without oritz..he was gone after 08

  • Madden History

    2008-2009- David Ortiz gets the shaft, and it is announced that Madden 10 will be headed by Ian Cummings, Ian and Co. proclaim a much needed new direction for Madden, despite the “EA Marketing team” directly on the other coin praising the successes of Madden 09 financially and gameplay wise in order to market Madden 10. Despite this back to basics profession, the producers decide to stick with the original heavily criticized engine to make their improvements on top of. Early impressions of the demo showed the same problems that plauged Madden 09, not suprisingly.

    Some say 2k football would never outsell Madden, but that was 5 years ago. Consider if the great 2k Football games were available each year after year, for the past 5 awful years of Madden. Consider if consumers had a choice. It is my belief that the exact same thing that happened with 2K basketball slowly taking over the market from EA Sports NBA Live in those same 5 years, would have happened with football. Maybe someone at EA recognized this, and pushed for the exclusive license.

    • pat

      actually madden 09 was the first madden that was without oritz..he was gone after 08

  • Eric Melo

    The Graphics are denfinatly a lot better. Look at Heinz field. In 09 it looks way too dark. in Madden 10 it looks more realistic!

  • Eric Melo

    The Graphics are denfinatly a lot better. Look at Heinz field. In 09 it looks way too dark. in Madden 10 it looks more realistic!

  • turf12

    i noticed that this year chris johnson looks more like chris johnson instead of just some generic black guy with dreads.

  • turf12

    i noticed that this year chris johnson looks more like chris johnson instead of just some generic black guy with dreads.

Sponsors
Categories
Featured Video
Quantcast