Madden Curse Strikes Early

by pastapadre
Posted September 14th, 2009 at 6:25 pm

madden10troy0914

In the NFL season opener, co-cover athlete for Madden 10 Troy Polamalu suffered what is currently being called an MCL sprain that will keep him out at least 3-6 weeks. This lead to the inevitable rush of Madden curse articles which has been the case for years now. Understandably when he was injured the initial reaction of many was to note that the cover curse had struck yet again. Many would argue that it just can’t be written off as a coincidence any longer with its consistency and in this case having happened so early in the season.

The other cover athlete Larry Fitzgerald did have six receptions for 71 yards and a TD on Sunday. However the Cardinals dropped the home opener to the 49ers and still have not won a game after going 0-4 in the preseason. That would certainly be more indicative of the difficulties teams have bouncing back after Super Bowl losses than anything to do with Madden.

Players on the cover are coming off exceptional seasons which are difficult to duplicate. They are coming off years that were largely injury free and that inevitably all players will face injuries in their career.  In reality it should be little surprise that cover athletes have a track record of struggling the years they are in the spotlight.

Do I feel that there is a curse on players who appear on the cover of Madden? No of course not. But what I do see now, thanks to avenues such as Twitter but also just regular media coverage, is that these players face questions about it and get the idea of it planted in their heads. After Polamalu went down it was Fitzgerald responding the tweets about the Madden curse. It is inescapable. Does that end up getting in their heads resulting in a higher likelihood of the instances we’ve seen throughout the history of the series? That would seem be the most legit aspect of what the supposed curse could mean.

Tom Brady wasn’t on the cover of Madden 09 yet he was lost last year for the whole season. A large percentage of players miss games or see their play level drop-off and don’t have a game cover to attribute that too. Brian Urlacher, Donovan McNabb and other players injured early this season were not on the cover…yet if they had been that is what people would be pointing towards. So while there is no actual curse the thought of it carries on and Fitzgerald will continue to deal with the weight of it throughout the year.

Tags:
  • Michael

    first

  • Michael

    first

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/MauGx3 MauGx3

    I think that Madden Curse is only psychological. Players get feared or overexcited by being on Madden NFL cover, so they get injured.

    But Larry Fitzgerald has a better mind control than Troy, so I don't think he will be injured.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/MauGx3 MauGx3

    I think that Madden Curse is only psychological. Players get feared or overexcited by being on Madden NFL cover, so they get injured.

    But Larry Fitzgerald has a better mind control than Troy, so I don't think he will be injured.

  • D-12

    McNabb was on a cover…………

  • D-12

    McNabb was on a cover…………

  • sdot

    @ PASTA did dat UPDATE 4 MADDEN come out on da PS3

    I got da updated rosters but DON'T recall D/L N e update & I want 2 TRY OUT dat BROADCAST CAMERA ANGLE

  • sdot

    @ PASTA did dat UPDATE 4 MADDEN come out on da PS3

    I got da updated rosters but DON'T recall D/L N e update & I want 2 TRY OUT dat BROADCAST CAMERA ANGLE

  • OPPS i meant

    the worst news of the year has to be urlacher going out for the season and now i think that the bears defense is going to miss a huge gap of leadership … but i heard that the chicago bears are tacking to derrick brooks …. BEAR DOWN!!!

  • OPPS i meant

    the worst news of the year has to be urlacher going out for the season and now i think that the bears defense is going to miss a huge gap of leadership … but i heard that the chicago bears are tacking to derrick brooks …. BEAR DOWN!!!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/acreyman acreyman

    LMFAO at the screen shot! that just looks funny. Dude it might not be a curse but you cant deny the coincidence.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/acreyman acreyman

    LMFAO at the screen shot! that just looks funny. Dude it might not be a curse but you cant deny the coincidence.

  • 686

    any news on the madden patch???

  • 686

    any news on the madden patch???

  • shogunoflive

    how can you say you dont believe in the curse when every year the guy on the cover gets hurt….Especially in the case of Vince Young who wasn't a vet that just put up another great year, but a 2nd year guy that shoulda had a even better year than the one before it

  • shogunoflive

    how can you say you dont believe in the curse when every year the guy on the cover gets hurt….Especially in the case of Vince Young who wasn't a vet that just put up another great year, but a 2nd year guy that shoulda had a even better year than the one before it

  • Tayler

    Seahawks neon green jerseys are for sure now! they were all over the stadium at the hawks game and i went to get one but they sold out. So will they be coming in a update or with the AFL DLC?

  • Tayler

    Seahawks neon green jerseys are for sure now! they were all over the stadium at the hawks game and i went to get one but they sold out. So will they be coming in a update or with the AFL DLC?

  • Matt

    Brady was on Backyard Football 09. I think that Backyard sports covers are jinxed too. Think about it David Ortiz was on Backyard Baseball and he is not having a good season this year.

  • Matt

    Brady was on Backyard Football 09. I think that Backyard sports covers are jinxed too. Think about it David Ortiz was on Backyard Baseball and he is not having a good season this year.

  • Kmart2180

    Id like to thank EA for putting Larry Fitz on the cover. By doing so it allowed for the 49ers secondary to be able to cover him Amazingly. Thanks again.

  • Kmart2180

    Id like to thank EA for putting Larry Fitz on the cover. By doing so it allowed for the 49ers secondary to be able to cover him Amazingly. Thanks again.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/AngelOfHeart AngelOfHeart

    lol….i think something strange is definatly going on here…after this season, ill wait to see what happens with Fitz..if, and IF he misses significant time, or faces a HUGE dropoff in performance..then ill start to put more credence into this curse

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/AngelOfHeart AngelOfHeart

    lol….i think something strange is definatly going on here…after this season, ill wait to see what happens with Fitz..if, and IF he misses significant time, or faces a HUGE dropoff in performance..then ill start to put more credence into this curse

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/sroeland sroeland

    So does this mean that Brian Urlacher is suffering from the NFL 2K3 cover curse?

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/sroeland sroeland

    So does this mean that Brian Urlacher is suffering from the NFL 2K3 cover curse?

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    You made an excellent point Pasta about how there are even more stars who aren't on the cover that have this kind of stuff happen to them. It's fun to joke about it, but there simply isn't a curse. People confuse a curse with odd statistic. I'll bet 100 bucks that Fitz has an All-Pro season this year and it won't be an issue.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    You made an excellent point Pasta about how there are even more stars who aren't on the cover that have this kind of stuff happen to them. It's fun to joke about it, but there simply isn't a curse. People confuse a curse with odd statistic. I'll bet 100 bucks that Fitz has an All-Pro season this year and it won't be an issue.

  • football-know-it-all

    I believe in curse……the only person that wasnt really effected was Ray lewis on the cover of madden 2005….he only got injured for one game

  • football-know-it-all

    I believe in curse……the only person that wasnt really effected was Ray lewis on the cover of madden 2005….he only got injured for one game

  • Rude Boy

    Off topic but I gotta vent!!! Who does the ratings!?! Do they not do any kind of stat study?!? I use the 49ers & Frank Gore has been fumbling A LOT!!!! So I looked it up last year he fumbled 6 times therefore his rating is 72 Marion Barber of Cowboy fame fumbled 7 times but his carry rating is 87!!! Adrian Peterson fumbled 9 TIMES LAST YEAR his rating is 70!!! Come on man thats a joke!!!

  • Rude Boy

    Off topic but I gotta vent!!! Who does the ratings!?! Do they not do any kind of stat study?!? I use the 49ers & Frank Gore has been fumbling A LOT!!!! So I looked it up last year he fumbled 6 times therefore his rating is 72 Marion Barber of Cowboy fame fumbled 7 times but his carry rating is 87!!! Adrian Peterson fumbled 9 TIMES LAST YEAR his rating is 70!!! Come on man thats a joke!!!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    Exactly….he didn't prove anything before they put him on the cover. They just as easily could have chosen Matt Leinart or Reggie Bush and both of those guys have been busts so far too.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    Exactly….he didn't prove anything before they put him on the cover. They just as easily could have chosen Matt Leinart or Reggie Bush and both of those guys have been busts so far too.

  • Rude Boy

    Let me add Steven Jackson had 5 fumbles but his carry rating is 85!!!

  • Rude Boy

    Let me add Steven Jackson had 5 fumbles but his carry rating is 85!!!

  • 555

    cuz gore sucks

  • 555

    cuz gore sucks

  • Rude Boy

    lol great answer you must be the smartest outta your entire family huh?? I bet you're a star athlete too so you know all about sports lol clown

  • Rude Boy

    lol great answer you must be the smartest outta your entire family huh?? I bet you're a star athlete too so you know all about sports lol clown

  • houdini

    LMAO at the screen shot lolz

  • houdini

    LMAO at the screen shot lolz

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Skihawks Skihawks

    I think Pasta reported that those will be patched in. I wish they would add Seattle's jerseys (home and away) from the 80's with the Seahawk logo on the sleeve. Those were awesome. Oh, and fix the logo on the classic helmets. Still don't have it right.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Skihawks Skihawks

    I think Pasta reported that those will be patched in. I wish they would add Seattle's jerseys (home and away) from the 80's with the Seahawk logo on the sleeve. Those were awesome. Oh, and fix the logo on the classic helmets. Still don't have it right.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Skihawks Skihawks

    Yet he got in trouble with the law for covering up a murder….Allegedly….

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Skihawks Skihawks

    Yet he got in trouble with the law for covering up a murder….Allegedly….

  • Scott

    homo

  • Scott

    homo

  • theron

    how can u say there is no curse.
    every player thats been on a madden cover has gotta injured.

    i think its more than just a coincidence if it happens EVERY YEAR!!
    i would say put madden back on the cover..but he might ….die :(

  • theron

    how can u say there is no curse.
    every player thats been on a madden cover has gotta injured.

    i think its more than just a coincidence if it happens EVERY YEAR!!
    i would say put madden back on the cover..but he might ….die :(

  • Rob

    and DeAngelo Williams fumbled 0 times yet his isn't a 99.

  • Rob

    and DeAngelo Williams fumbled 0 times yet his isn't a 99.

  • jo momma

    not anymore, they're just gonna start hillenmeyer

  • jo momma

    not anymore, they're just gonna start hillenmeyer

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisJNelson ChrisJNelson

    People that believe believe in the Madden Curse are brainless morons. Don't forget to leave cookies out for Santa.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisJNelson ChrisJNelson

    Football is a contact sport, moron.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisJNelson ChrisJNelson

    People that believe believe in the Madden Curse are brainless morons. Don't forget to leave cookies out for Santa.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisJNelson ChrisJNelson

    Football is a contact sport, moron.

  • benjamin97

    FUNNY PIC OF TROY

  • benjamin97

    FUNNY PIC OF TROY

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/dagamesta dagamesta

    The curse is alive and well.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/dagamesta dagamesta

    The curse is alive and well.

  • LULU

    ONLY IN THE WEAK MINDED.

  • LULU

    ONLY IN THE WEAK MINDED.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/dagamesta dagamesta

    Oh, you must be a Steelers fan. Sorry about the sand in your VAGINA!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/dagamesta dagamesta

    Oh, you must be a Steelers fan. Sorry about the sand in your VAGINA!

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    You made an excellent point Pasta about how there are even more stars who aren't on the cover that have this kind of stuff happen to them. It's fun to joke about, but it simply isn't true. People confuse a curse with an odd statistic. I'll bet 100 bucks that Fitz has an All-Pro season this year and it won't be an issue.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Sidewinder Sidewinder

    You made an excellent point Pasta about how there are even more stars who aren't on the cover that have this kind of stuff happen to them. It's fun to joke about, but it simply isn't true. People confuse a curse with an odd statistic. I'll bet 100 bucks that Fitz has an All-Pro season this year and it won't be an issue.

  • Bisett

    "The person who said Live's commentary is better then 2k's. You meant 2k9 correct. " -sdot

    At least I believe you were stating this. I have been studying Ebonics at UCLA so I hope that's right

    LOL.Yes I meant in 2k9 I have not heard 2k10 commentary but I am happy that you stated that the

    commentary sounds good in 2k10.

    Spelling Help

    sed= said

    BETTA = better

    Cuz = Because

    da= the

    dey = they

    2nd= Second

    I KNO U AINT play = I know you have not played 2k10

    Deer = There

    Aint No = There isn't

    4 u 2 = For You Too

    I hope those ebonics quotes are right I need an B+ to pass LoL

  • Bisett

    "The person who said Live's commentary is better then 2k's. You meant 2k9 correct. " -sdot

    At least I believe you were stating this. I have been studying Ebonics at UCLA so I hope that's right

    LOL.Yes I meant in 2k9 I have not heard 2k10 commentary but I am happy that you stated that the

    commentary sounds good in 2k10.

    Spelling Help

    sed= said

    BETTA = better

    Cuz = Because

    da= the

    dey = they

    2nd= Second

    I KNO U AINT play = I know you have not played 2k10

    Deer = There

    Aint No = There isn't

    4 u 2 = For You Too

    I hope those ebonics quotes are right I need an B+ to pass LoL

  • Curse

    Just wanted to review the curse:

    1999: Garrison Hearst was on select covers of Madden 1999. Hearst had an outstanding regular season, finishing third in rushing yards. Hearst suffered a broken ankle in the divisional playoff game against the Atlanta Falcons. The severe break required Hearst to miss two full NFL seasons.

    2000: Barry Sanders is pictured over Madden's left shoulder on the cover. Sanders abruptly retired in July before the start of the 1999 season.

    2001: Eddie George's curse came in 2001 where he failed to break 1000 yards and Tennessee missed the playoffs going 7-9.

    2002: Dante Culpepper missed 4 games with injury, threw for 1300 less yards and 19 less TD's then in 2000. Minnesota's worst record since 1984.

    2003: Marshall Faulk: Despite playing the same amount of games, Faulk rushed for 430 less yards and had 4 less TDs compared to 2001. Faulk's worst season since 1996. Rams scored only 16 more points then their 1996 team who had Tony Banks at QB and Lawrence Phillips at RB.

    2004: Vick missed the first 11 games with a broken leg. Vick's QB rating, comp pct, and yards per attempt were all down from 2002.

    2005: Ray Lewis for the most part avoided the curse. His numbers were slightly down from the year before, but he missed one game. He did not record an interception in 2004, the first time in his career.

    2006: After week 9, Mcnabb suffered a hernia and was lost for the season. Mcnabb threw for more interceptions and his yards per attempt and completion percentage were down from 2004. The Eagles finished 6-10, in last place, and missed the playoffs for the first time since 1999.

    2007: Shaun Alexander missed 6 regular season games with a broken foot. He finished the season with 896 yards and a 3.6 yard per carry average (well down from his 4.4 career yard per carry average). His 896 yards and 7 touchdowns were the lowest since his rookie season.

    2008: Vince Young finished with 9 touchdowns and 17 interceptions, but completed 62% of his passes and Tennessee went 10-6, losing to the Chargers in the first round of the playoffs.

    2009: Favre and the Jets started the season hot, but after Favre injured his throwing arm, the season collapsed quickly. Favre threw 6 less TD's and 7 more int's then in 2007. The Jets finished 9-7 after starting 8-3 and missed the playoffs.

    2010: Troy is injured and the Fitzgerald still has 15 games to go…we all know the Cards are missing the playoffs too.

    I say the "curse" is pretty consistent and always a fun discussion. Yes Tom Brady was injured but didn't he appear on the cover of Backyard Football (I think someone else noted that). Urlacher appeared on 2k3…so perhaps we could change it to the video game coverboy curse. Anyways, the whole Madden curse is alive and well and works like clockwork.

  • Curse

    Just wanted to review the curse:

    1999: Garrison Hearst was on select covers of Madden 1999. Hearst had an outstanding regular season, finishing third in rushing yards. Hearst suffered a broken ankle in the divisional playoff game against the Atlanta Falcons. The severe break required Hearst to miss two full NFL seasons.

    2000: Barry Sanders is pictured over Madden's left shoulder on the cover. Sanders abruptly retired in July before the start of the 1999 season.

    2001: Eddie George's curse came in 2001 where he failed to break 1000 yards and Tennessee missed the playoffs going 7-9.

    2002: Dante Culpepper missed 4 games with injury, threw for 1300 less yards and 19 less TD's then in 2000. Minnesota's worst record since 1984.

    2003: Marshall Faulk: Despite playing the same amount of games, Faulk rushed for 430 less yards and had 4 less TDs compared to 2001. Faulk's worst season since 1996. Rams scored only 16 more points then their 1996 team who had Tony Banks at QB and Lawrence Phillips at RB.

    2004: Vick missed the first 11 games with a broken leg. Vick's QB rating, comp pct, and yards per attempt were all down from 2002.

    2005: Ray Lewis for the most part avoided the curse. His numbers were slightly down from the year before, but he missed one game. He did not record an interception in 2004, the first time in his career.

    2006: After week 9, Mcnabb suffered a hernia and was lost for the season. Mcnabb threw for more interceptions and his yards per attempt and completion percentage were down from 2004. The Eagles finished 6-10, in last place, and missed the playoffs for the first time since 1999.

    2007: Shaun Alexander missed 6 regular season games with a broken foot. He finished the season with 896 yards and a 3.6 yard per carry average (well down from his 4.4 career yard per carry average). His 896 yards and 7 touchdowns were the lowest since his rookie season.

    2008: Vince Young finished with 9 touchdowns and 17 interceptions, but completed 62% of his passes and Tennessee went 10-6, losing to the Chargers in the first round of the playoffs.

    2009: Favre and the Jets started the season hot, but after Favre injured his throwing arm, the season collapsed quickly. Favre threw 6 less TD's and 7 more int's then in 2007. The Jets finished 9-7 after starting 8-3 and missed the playoffs.

    2010: Troy is injured and the Fitzgerald still has 15 games to go…we all know the Cards are missing the playoffs too.

    I say the "curse" is pretty consistent and always a fun discussion. Yes Tom Brady was injured but didn't he appear on the cover of Backyard Football (I think someone else noted that). Urlacher appeared on 2k3…so perhaps we could change it to the video game coverboy curse. Anyways, the whole Madden curse is alive and well and works like clockwork.

  • Curse

    just wanted to add Ray Lewis had an injured wrist for the last couple of games that season he appeared on the cover.

  • Curse

    just wanted to add Ray Lewis had an injured wrist for the last couple of games that season he appeared on the cover.

  • funbob

    Players who've reached the point in their careers that they're likely to make the cover will tend to have a few years' starting experience, and cover athletes are more likely to come from teams who made the playoffs or won the Superbowl, so additional wear and tear is going to be more likely for your average cover athlete than your average player at large.

    It'd be interesting to see how many of the players got hurt if they started putting rookies on the cover and more up-and-comers. Young, etc.

  • funbob

    Players who've reached the point in their careers that they're likely to make the cover will tend to have a few years' starting experience, and cover athletes are more likely to come from teams who made the playoffs or won the Superbowl, so additional wear and tear is going to be more likely for your average cover athlete than your average player at large.

    It'd be interesting to see how many of the players got hurt if they started putting rookies on the cover and more up-and-comers. Young, etc.

  • Loz

    Maybe Brady was supposed to be on the cover of MAdden 09, but Farve got it because Madden has a man crush on him and thought this would be the last chance to put him on the cover. In other words Brady got robbed the cover yet still got injured.

  • Loz

    Maybe Brady was supposed to be on the cover of MAdden 09, but Farve got it because Madden has a man crush on him and thought this would be the last chance to put him on the cover. In other words Brady got robbed the cover yet still got injured.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Sponsors
Subscription Options:
Categories
Tags
Featured Video
Quantcast