Top 50 historic players in March Madness 08

by pastapadre
Posted November 10th, 2007 at 2:36 am

MM08

The top 50 rated all-time players in March Madness 08 has been posted by Gamespot. These are overall ratings of the best of the players from the classic teams in the game. If you missed it you can check out the complete list of classic teams here and the ratings of the top current players in the game here.

Clearly the most controversial placing on the list will be Kevin Durant coming in at #2. He had undeniably one of if not the best freshman year of any player in history. However he did only play only the one year which makes it more difficult to justify placing him over some of the most legendary names to have played college basketball.

Also revealed in the screenshots posted by Gamespot is that the teams appear to have their classic uniforms and in the fit style of the times.

I begin the top 50 players below. Continue on to view the entire list.

1. Michael Jordan — North Carolina — 96
2. Kevin Durant — Texas — 94
3. Earvin Johnson — Michigan State — 94
4. Clyde Drexler — Houston — 92
5. Larry Bird — Indiana State — 92
6. Steve Nash — Santa Clara — 91
7. Kenny Anderson — Georgia Tech — 89
8. Chris Bosh — Georgia Tech — 89
9. Richard Hamilton — Connecticut — 89
10. Jamal Mashburn — Kentucky — 89

11. Jason Terry — Arizona — 89
12. Reggie Williams — Georgetown — 89
13. Ray Allen — Connecticut — 88
14. Carmelo Anthony — Syracuse — 88
15. Butch Beard — Louisville — 88
16. Travis Best — Georgia Tech — 88
17. Mike Bibby — Arizona — 88
18. Junior Bridgeman — Louisville — 88
19. Caron Butler — Connecticut — 88
20. Mike Dunleavy — Duke — 88
21. Ben Gordon — Connecticut — 88
22. Chris Jackson — LSU — 88
23. Kevin Jackson — California — 88
24. Jason Kidd — California — 88
25. Christian Laettner — Duke — 88

26. Randy Livingston — LSU — 88
27. Kenyon Martin — Cincinnati — 88
28. Rashad McCants — North Carolina — 88
29. Laron Profit — Maryland — 88
30. Oscar Robertson — Cincinnati — 88
31. Jerry Stackhouse — North Carolina — 88
32. Charlie Tyra — Louisville — 88
33. John Wallace — Syracuse — 88
34. Derek Anderson — Kentucky — 87
35. Keith Bogans — Kentucky — 87
36. Sean Elliott — Arizona — 87
37. Brian Evans — Indiana — 87
38. Art Heyman — Duke — 87
39. Larry Johnson — UNLV — 87
40. DeMarr Johnson — Cincinnati — 87
41. Pete Maravich — LSU — 87
42. Stephon Marbury — Georgia Tech — 87
43. Ron Mercer — Kentucky — 87
44. Andrew Miller — Utah — 87
45. Chris Mills — Arizona — 87
46. Joakim Noah — Florida — 87
47. Ed O’Bannon — UCLA — 87
48. Glen Rice — Michigan — 87
49. Cliff Robertson — Connecticut — 87
50. Dennis Scott — Georgia Tech — 87

Tags:
  • slamfan
    how is pistol pete under 90??????? 40+ ppg, BEST in college, and they give him lower than 90????
  • Eski
    I guess people can't read....Some players mentioned in a number of posts are not in the game because their team is not in the game. What part of that is difficult to understand???

    The classic players that were rated, I agree some rated much lower or higher than they should be, are players that are in the game....Mateen Cleaves (I am a huge MSU fan) is not in the game...Shaq, not there either....Should be but isn't..
  • G
    [quote comment="5966"]i will tell you exactly why jordan is the highest rated historic player...because unlike the NBA...college basketball is all about team work and non-selfish play...jordan may have been the greatest player in NBA history...and what many people often forget is that he was also the greatest TEAM player to ever play the game...he helped some good and some marginal players on his team become superstars and pivotal role players...with that being said, when it came to crunch time...with the game on the line...jordan was going to get the ball and seal the victory...check out the '84 national championship if you disagree with me...i don't care that he was drafted 3rd...he won the naismith and wooden POY awards...olajuwon went to houston first, who desperately needed a big man and he also happened to player for the University of Houston (it was about marketing as much as talent)...and come on...sam bowie went 2nd? not only was this purely a team need pick...but with jordan, barkley, and stockton still on the draft board...this easily made ESPNs list of 100 worst draft picks ever...[/quote]

    I'll start this off by saying Jordan is the greatest player ever(NBA). Kareem is the greatest college player ever and it's not even an argument. 3 years, 3 championships, 3 MOPs, 88-2 record.

    But LOL. You are clueless. First, it wasn't the 1984 title game. It was the 1982 title game. And that team was James Worthy's team. Jordan was a little known freshmen who hit a big shot(open shot, because G'town doubled off him). How did 1983 and 1984 go? Any titles? His collegiate career was nothing special. Jordan was the greatest TEAM player ever? Um, hell no he wasn't. Magic Johnson or Bill Russell hold that title. Do you know ANYTHING about Jordan? Prior to his title years this guy was a complete ballhog and bashed the shit out of all his teammates. When they asked him about making his teammates better, he'd say get me better teammates.

    If MJ was the greatest college player, he would have been the #1 pick regardless of position.
  • Jonathon
    i will tell you exactly why jordan is the highest rated historic player...because unlike the NBA...college basketball is all about team work and non-selfish play...jordan may have been the greatest player in NBA history...and what many people often forget is that he was also the greatest TEAM player to ever play the game...he helped some good and some marginal players on his team become superstars and pivotal role players...with that being said, when it came to crunch time...with the game on the line...jordan was going to get the ball and seal the victory...check out the '84 national championship if you disagree with me...i don't care that he was drafted 3rd...he won the naismith and wooden POY awards...olajuwon went to houston first, who desperately needed a big man and he also happened to player for the University of Houston (it was about marketing as much as talent)...and come on...sam bowie went 2nd? not only was this purely a team need pick...but with jordan, barkley, and stockton still on the draft board...this easily made ESPNs list of 100 worst draft picks ever...
  • Bumble14
    [quote comment="5921"]Bill Walton, Lew Alcindor, Ralph Sampson, Len Bias, David Robinson, David Thompson, Oscar Robertson, Iverson? I can't say enough about how awful this list is. I may need to make another 10 posts to describe how terrible this list is.[/quote]

    I posted before I read this post,but if I could, I would like to add this to my above post- because I couldn't agree more!!!!
  • Bumble14
    This is just a disgrace EA. It's as if these guys rated the players based SOLELY on their performancein the NBA, and not in college. How many great college players have their been that were total busts in the NBA? Where is Mateen Cleaves, one of the greatest leaders and college players in the history of the game. Where is Khalid El Amein? AND FOR GOD'S SAKE, WHERE IS BILL WALTON?? I mean the guy was only the centerpiece of the greatest college dynasty ever. James Worthy is apparently a scrub as well.

    Dear EA March Madness development team- how about you guys actually study the history of the game you are trying to make into a video game, and then come out with your ratings. Good Job on Kevin Durant though- I mean he was clearly a better college player than Isaih Thomas, Magic, Bird, Greg Kelser,and so many others.

    Ohh yeah..where's Patrick Ewing? At least we have Mike Dunleavy rated pretty high! Give me a break EA- poor.
  • cocobee
    Chris Webber and Larry Johnson need to be in the Top 10.

    In the pics, it looks like 82 UNC is wearing new baggy shorts uniforms, I wish they had the short shorts for them.
  • G
    [quote comment="5932"]the list is borked... plain and simple

    and lol @ Jordan not being a #2 pick... jesus he was #3, could you nitpick more?[/quote]


    So the "greatest college player ever" wasn't the #1 or #2 pick? Does that make any sense? James Worthy, a teammate of his at UNC, was a better collegiate player, and oh, he went #1. And Magic Johnson was unquestionably a better collegiate player. Oh, and he went #1.

    Here's the best analogy. It would be like saying Dwyane Wade was better in college then Carmelo Anthony. Hell no he wasn't.
  • Eski
    If EA includes classic teams with the jersey numbers, that is fine by me. I can always edit the player names. Classic rosters would be a good thing to swap with the EA locker system.
  • Eski
    Hey Greg, 2006-07 OSU is not in the game. If you would have won you, and OSU, would have been in the game.

    Good luck next year.
  • Greg Oden
    Where the hell am I???? I am a number one pick. I helped guide Ohio State to the National Title game. I put up better stats than Joakim Noah....hell, I'm better looking than Joakim Noah.

    EA's just mad that I didn't sign with them- that is all.
  • Eski
    A couple of items:

    1) Shaq isn't in the game because there are no LSU teams in the game with which he played on. He was not at LSU in 1990.

    2) I agree in regards to Jordan. He was good in college but not 96 good. His first few years with the Bulls, he shot like 43%.

    3) I hate Duke and I hated Laettner. However, he was a much better college player and should be at least a 90. Dunleavy was not the college player Chrissy was.
  • sean
    christian laetner was a better college player than any of these guys and his team is in the game. 4 year starter, All time NCAA tourny scoring leader and most clutch college player ever.
  • chiahatesyou
    the list is borked... plain and simple

    and lol @ Jordan not being a #2 pick... jesus he was #3, could you nitpick more?
  • [quote comment="5930"]is that the same reason that we don't have old teams in madden anymore?[/quote]

    I'm not sure really. There probably is a reason for that because if they could have those teams (even if it meant not using names) I think they probably would. Or it could be something simple like a time issue where they had to concentrate on other aspects of the game. They have some HOF players in but they've had to pay them.
  • Alex
    is that the same reason that we don't have old teams in madden anymore?
  • [quote comment="5928"]so why don't they put the old bulls squad on Live, so we can play as
    Jordan and Pippen[/quote]

    licensing issue. The amount of money they would have to pay to do that would be extraordinary because they would need to sign each player individually to a deal.
  • Alex
    so why don't they put the old bulls squad on Live, so we can play as
    Jordan and Pippen
  • One thing to consider is the player's team has to be in the game. This isn't a list of the greatest players of all-time but it is limited to players who are in the game because they're on a classic team.

    So for example David Robinson. His Navy team isn't in the game. Thats why he wouldn't be in this list.
  • Alex
    wait i got a question, Why is Jordan in March Madness and not Live or any other basketball game?
  • G
    Bill Walton, Lew Alcindor, Ralph Sampson, Len Bias, David Robinson, David Thompson, Oscar Robertson, Iverson? I can't say enough about how awful this list is. I may need to make another 10 posts to describe how terrible this list is.
  • G
    And Shaq isn't even on the list? EA fails. They should all be slapped.
  • G
    Jordan's overrated. Too biased based on his career. He was a great player, but he wasn't even a top 2 pick in the draft.

    And there's a picture of Kareem, but he's not on the list?

    Nash a 91? Are you kidding me?

    Some of these ratings are WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY to biased on pro success.
  • Michael
    I think its funny that Joakim Noah is on the list when Al Horford was our best player.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Sponsors
Subscription Options:
Categories
Tags
Featured Video
Quantcast