Player Face Comparisons: 2K9 vs The Show

by pastapadre
Posted March 11th, 2009 at 8:52 am

johnsoncomparison

Now that everyone knows how MLB 2K9 and MLB 09 The Show turned out I thought it would be fun to compare some of the player faces from the games. Doing so always results in an interesting post-release discussion.

I randomly selected 10 well known players and in comparable situations. All images were taken through the HD PVR via component with 2K9 being the 360 version vs The Show PS3. Which game do you think came out on top the most?

MLB 2K9 – Daisuke Matsuzaka – MLB 09 The Show

daisukecomparison

MLB 2K9 – Prince Fielder – MLB 09 The Show

fieldercomparison

MLB 2K9 – Ken Griffey Jr – MLB 09 The Show

griffeycomparison

MLB 2K9 – Matt Holliday – MLB 09 The Show

hollidaycomparison

MLB 2K9 – Randy Johnson – MLB 09 The Show

johnsoncomparison

MLB 2K9 – Francisco Rodriguez – MLB 09 The Show

krodcomparison

MLB 2K9 – Cliff Lee – MLB 09 The Show

leecomparison

MLB 2K9 – Albert Pujols – MLB 09 The Show

pujolscomparison

MLB 2K9 – Vladimir Guerrero – MLB 09 The Show

vladcomparison

MLB 2K9 – Manny Ramirez – MLB 09 The Show

mannycomparison

Tags: latest news

nasty nate

you can see the sweat on big daddy vladdys hat on the show. badass. show wins

Ryan

MLB is the better game, end of story,

Coon1010

Manny looks terrible on both games

Ramiah

The show wins this. (both griffey's look horrible!)

2K9 fan

Well besides the fact that randy johnson is set up like a righty in the 09 Show version, i don't see much of a difference. Manny looks fine in the 2k9 version, and both griffey's look like shit. So yea, thats my take.

Thomas

This is off the subject but those of you who have the SHOW could you please give me your opinions on the accuracy of the stadiums? Have you found them right on or are some missing something? Thanks all and have a great day.

J-Man

9-1 the show wins the only good 2k9 one was fielder

poo-k-sports

i truly cant believe theres even a debate. just look at the pictures or the videos. mlb 2k9 is the 2nd worst sports game ever made, after 2k8 of course. its a testament to how truly lazy 2k is. they release 50 crappy baseball titles a year in hopes of making a little money, yet if they would invest some time and effort into just one, then maybe there would actually be some competition for the show. so quit whining all you 360 owners. you get to sit another year on the bench waiting for 2k's next horribly embarrassing installment.

Yea Yea

2K Sports' work ethic when it comes to their MLB license is piss poor and they need to take it more seriously. The fact that they hold the official license is amazing.

Yea Yea

MLB The Show's skin textures and lighting is what makes MLB 2K9 look very bad in comparison. SCEA worked longer and harder that 2K did and it shows.

anthony

7-3 for the show. 2K9's manny, pujols and k-rod are better

RDE

I think they are all terrible they need to go to NBALIVE.com and learn how to make cyberfaces

jeffy777@gmail.com

Honestly, both games have ugly faces. It's like picking the less of two evils.

pudge

why do people care so much about player faces, you don't ever get a real close up picture. And if you have a PS3 you like MLB the show because no one gives 2k9 a chance. If your a 360 owner you like mlb 2k9

Pasta Padre

No question 2K9 has the better faces here. I give The Show Randy Johnson and Vlad, and that's it.

-Pasta Padre

LATEROLUS

do anybody knows how to put your created player to play in the game? thank you Laterolus.

Whatev

Not even close ... he looks too cartoony fake, in The Show he looks real.

Zane

Griffey in 2K....

Zane

Look at Griffey......HE LOOKS TERRIBLE!!!

idontknow

Hey Padre, how about a stadium comparison? I think that would cool to who got the stadius down pat to a tee, especially the new Mets & Yankees.

pastapadre

Not sure that would be fair to either side. They both had to basically make educated guesses on the new stadiums.

TigerTony

The Show kills 2k. Not only are the faces better in terms of accuracy, but also in texture. The 2k faces all look like they're made out of cardboard.

Tone

2k9 is for little kids and people that dont understand losing makes you better.
First time I played the 2k9 demo I hit 13 HRs... In 2 innings...
The Show has better features, smoother game play, and realistic AI and stats.
Did no one else watch the videos in pastas 2k9 wrap up?

pastapadre

Just curious, why do you want a face comparison 6 months after the games have been released? Not sure I see the point.

Chipper Jones

I am Chipper Jones and i am a pu$$y as well....

Chipper Jones

I am Chipper Jones and i endorse NBA 2k9

Bl4ziNbuLLd0G

Manny looks like a fat Puerto Rican on The Show.....

AmenRa

NBA2k9 is better than NBA live 09 and The Show is better than MLB2k9, it ain't about platforms or game makers it's about the truth period.

JHeb

Griffey is horrible in both of them...Lee too. My only issue with The Show are the eyes. They're almost all too light looking. Makes the players look very odd. Most people have darker eyes even if they're blue, green, etc. Weird.

bumblebee

wrong-sorry 2x

bumblebee

I spelled wronged...lol...sorry. Oh btw The show is the true baseball game, but let´s do a compare faces for all games then.

bumblebee

let´s does a face comparison for NBA live 09 and NBA2k9...
Or is it true that padre is a 2k hater?

adam

mlb 2k9 wins 6 to 4. People are going to be biased on this topic because the shows better. Tell how you think instead of finding a way to bash 2k9,or fit in with everybody. The Shows Manny takes the cake for worst image of this group.

aaron

2k9=cartoon, the show=real

pastapadre

Comments should be back to normal now.

SeaTownSwag

Manny and Cliff Lee look bad on both.I give Prince to 2K9 maybe Pujols and maybe K-rod but all the rest go to the show.

Scott B.

You should have included a real shot for comparison too.

Jonathon

both look REALLY creepy at times...what happened to Ken Griffey Jr.'s face? haha...

pastapadre

Comment problem being worked on. Until then I switched by to the generic comment system.

idontknow

Wow, none of them are great. Why do all the white guys in the show have cat eyes. and all the colored guys have brown eyes? I think there both poorly done. Look at the faces for MVP '05 and compare them with these two games, no competition.

blog comments powered by Disqus